Editorial 15 January 2019

Jasmine Solana

Under China’s new blockchain laws, Bitmain-ABC’s BCH is in trouble

More legal trouble is coming Bitmain’s way, this time courtesy of China’s internet regulator.

On January 10, the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC) outlined the final draft of its regulations for the management of blockchain information services in the country. The rules, which will come into effect on February 15, aims to guard national security and public interest, and protect the rights of its citizens and legal entities, while also promoting the development of blockchain technology and related services in the country.

Under the new regulations, blockchain information service providers are within the purview of the CAC and a range of penalties has been outlined for the violation of the provisions.

What does this mean for Bitmain?

A CAC official defines a blockchain service provider as “the main body or node that provides the blockchain information service to the public, and the organization or organization that provides technical support for the blockchain information service.” Beijing-based Bitmain Technologies Holding Company describes itself as “China’s second largest and among the world’s top ten fabless IC design companies in terms of revenue in 2017.” In addition, the company manages some 11 mining farms in Sichuan Province, Zinjiang and Inner Mongolia, offering custodian services for customers’ mining hardware, and also operates mining pools—BTC.com and Antpool.

According to the new CAC regulations, blockchain service providers need to implement “information content security management responsibility” and a “true identity information authentication system,” among other things.

For Bitmain, this identity authentication system may mean that its miners can be held accountable for validating toxic transactions like OP_DATASIGVERIFY (OP_DSV), also known as OP_CHECKDATASIG. This is an opcode, not contained in the original Satoshi protocol, which ABC added to BCH during the November protocol upgrade.

Founding President of bComm Association Jimmy Nguyen has already warned of the legal risks that OP_DSV presented as it knowingly introduces illegal transactions into the BCH chain. He explained:

“Like any technology feature, op codes can be used for both lawful and non-lawful purposes. The problem for OP_DSV is that its key proponents vocally proclaim uses cases that are, at best, legally problematic, and at worst, clearly illegal. This makes it apparent up front that code developers and companies which then use DSV transactions for those problematic purposes know or “reasonably foresee” that OP_DSV can be used for illegal activity.”

This is one of the many reasons why Bitcoin SV opposes the enabling of non-Satoshi opcodes—not only do they present legal risks, but it’s clear that the original Bitcoin protocol has everything it needs to enable development. Bitcoin SV is the simpler approach to not just restore the original Bitcoin protocol, but also keep it stable and allow it to massively scale. As Nguyen puts it, “In order to achieve the Satoshi Vision – a world where big businesses and billions of people use Bitcoin – we need the [Bitcoin] network to operate in the real world. Bitcoin must meet the needs of real businesses, real people, and real laws.”

Note: Tokens on the Bitcoin Core (SegWit) chain are referenced as BTC coins; tokens on the Bitcoin Cash ABC chain are referenced as BCH, BCH-ABC or BAB coins.

Bitcoin Satoshi Vision (BSV) is today the only Bitcoin project that follows the original Satoshi Nakamoto whitepaper, and that follows the original Satoshi protocol and design. BSV is the only public blockchain that maintains the original vision for Bitcoin and will massively scale to become the world’s new money and enterprise blockchain.

COMMENT

latest news

Bitcoin SV is ready for the world’s business

Editorial 14 February 2019

Bitcoin SV is ready for the world’s business

The Bitcoin world hasn’t been short of amazing, with several new developments since Bitcoin was revitalized in November 2018. Bitcoin SV is proving that by following Satoshi’s original plan of keeping a stable protocol and pursuing massive on chain scaling, it opens up incredible new possibilities.

Read More
Cryptocurrency and Valentine’s Day are surprisingly similar

Editorial 14 February 2019

Cryptocurrency and Valentine’s Day are surprisingly similar

Today is February 14 – Saint Valentine’s Day. If you forgot to prepare a gift for the special person in your life, you have now been reminded and there’s no excuse.

Read More
Think twice before adding illegal content to Bitcoin SV chain

Editorial 5 February 2019

Think twice before adding illegal content to Bitcoin SV chain

After Bitcoin SV (BSV) Node developers and miners lifted the OP_Return data size limits to 100KB, activity immediately took off as users started posting texts, videos and even pictures.

Read More