Editorial 23 May 2017

Eli Afram

What Real Leadership Looks Like

When developers build an open source community project that ends up being backed by millions, and sometimes billions, of dollars, there comes a shift in responsibility. A developer of any major crypto-currency becomes entrusted to lead the way, to improve, to enhance, and to galvanize the support of those invested.

It’s no easy feat. The level of responsibility that developers take on, and the burden they carry, can sometimes be overwhelming. It is therefore not a job for the faint of heart, but let me also stress it is certainly not a job for those who simply lack good leadership skills.

Ethereum’s market share recently passed 50% of Bitcoin’s total and it should be noted that Ethereum has also recently become more profitable to mine than Bitcoin. This change in dominance, and the move in network effect, has been termed as the “flippening”.

It never needed to happen.

With solid leadership, Bitcoin could have been everything it is today and much more. To be a part of a lead development team for a multi-billion dollar community project means that you need to have skills that extend far beyond mere coding. This means listening and taking feedback from users, businesses, investors, economists, and the greater eco-system. Forging relationships can build integrity. Perhaps one of the most important attributes, however, is trust. Without establishing trust, like in any structure requiring some leadership, there is no direction, and hence no progress.

So we find ourselves in limbo on the Bitcoin front. We are eternally trapped at an artificial 1MB blocksize, which doesn’t appear set to increase any time soon. Segwit and Lightning Networks seem even further away. No matter the direction of Bitcoin, one thing for certain is that Core have failed to unite and galvanize the community.

Although Bitcoin is heavily losing its marketshare, the true extent of the fallout has yet to be realized. And it won’t be pretty.

Ironically, Ethereum’s leadership has had its share of challenges. It wasn’t too long ago when “The DAO” smart contract was deployed and then revoked with all funds restored to investors through a hardfork deployed by the Ethereum Foundation. The ‘refund’ hardfork was initiated after it was discovered an ‘attacker’ started siphoning investor’s money after identifying a loophole in the programming of the contract. The “Code is Law” catchphrase was now suddenly in question. Ethereum was no longer immutable it seemed, and “Ethereum Classic” was suddenly born from a minority forked chain. While it was a community decision to enact the hardfork, questions remain over the approach, and the default option on the client which was preselected to hardfork.

So what does real leadership look like?

That answer landed on my lap a week ago, when Monero developer Riccardo “fluffypony” Spagni, posted a full disclosure of a major bug discovered in Monero’s software. I wasn’t so much impressed with the disclosure of this bug, but moreso, as to how it was handled, and particularly with the efforts and communications undertaken with the wider crypto community.

It was in February earlier this year in fact that a member of Monero Research Lab discovered an exploit which affects all CryptoNote-based currencies which allows for the creation of an unlimited number of coins in a way that is undetectable to an observer. The Monero team immediately took the appropriate steps and scanned the blockchain to see if it was compromised – thankfully it wasn’t. A vulnerability quickly then patched along with a host of other changes which did well to conceal its criticality. The patch was rushed out under the guise of preventing a DoS attack (in order to urge miners and exchanges to upgrade). Once Monero’s network was updated, Monero’s dev team took charge of the issue and notified dev teams of all affected coins – that is, all cryptos based on the cryptonote protocol. These dev teams were given a one month timeline to upgrade their software, and last week Monero devs disclosed all the details of these events.

What Real Leadership Looks Like

Figure 1 – The Fix

This was a large vulnerability which could have compromised the Monero blockchain, as well as the integrity of every other Cryptonote coin out there – which no doubt would have sent investors panicking. Monero Core’s measured response, however, kept the entire drama under cover, did not raise suspicion, ensured no damage was done, and furthermore went on to make sure that other competing coins were also not affected. At the end of it all, a full disclosure was made by Riccardo Spagni on Monero’s official blog.

It is this sort of behavior which yields trust, and confidence. And as I mentioned “trust” is pivotal in leadership.

There need to be no “secret meetings”, back-door deals, uncompromising positions on roadmaps, and scalability efforts.

Sadly, with the current Bitcoin Core dev team, cries for change, or compromise in scaling, fall on deaf ears. Recently CEO of BitPay Stephen Pair tweeted “a typical #bitcoin transaction costs $1.80 now, >200k unconfirmed transactions, time for a hard fork to larger blocks … 8mb please”.

In today’s modern age, leaders cannot be dictators. Leaders need to listen, sometimes compromise, adapt to changing conditions, and ultimately unite a community. Monero dev’s approach is truly an example to the greater crypto-community. One that we hope can be learnt from.

Eli Afram M.IT
Developer/Analyst
@justicemate

Note: Tokens on the Bitcoin Core (SegWit) chain are referenced as BTC coins; tokens on the Bitcoin Cash ABC chain are referenced as BCH, BCH-ABC or BAB coins.

Bitcoin Satoshi Vision (BSV) is today the only Bitcoin project that follows the original Satoshi Nakamoto whitepaper, and that follows the original Satoshi protocol and design. BSV is the only public blockchain that maintains the original vision for Bitcoin and will massively scale to become the world’s new money and enterprise blockchain.

COMMENT

latest news

Continued Bitcoin Cash developer infighting shows a problematic future

Editorial 15 May 2019

Continued Bitcoin Cash developer infighting shows a problematic future

There is already a certain degree of harmonic dissonance among BCH developers, as witnessed by the discussion between Amaury Séchet and Jonathan Toomim.

Read More
BSV is ready for the world’s business. Are you?

Editorial 8 May 2019

BSV is ready for the world’s business. Are you?

Because Bitcoin SV offers unlimited possibilities, it's created a Cambrian explosion of creativity and innovation.

Read More
Bitcoin SV could surge as Bitfinex and Tether scandal unravels

Editorial 7 May 2019

Bitcoin SV could surge as Bitfinex and Tether scandal unravels

All the information coming out around Bitfinex seems to suggest that the price of BTC is being artificially pumped, while BSV is being held back. That might soon change.

Read More
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]
[data-clipboard-demo]