Tech 10 August 2018

Erik Gibbs

Rick Falkvinge talks BTC’s confusing narrative

In a recent video publised on YouTube by cryptocurrency expert Rick Falkvinge, he provides some enlightenment over “false narratives” being released by Bitcoin Core (BTC). He cites examples such as a story found on the Reddit r/bitcoin forum, which, once the original post is examined properly, is proven to be full of erroneous data, poor comparisons and a plethora of false narratives.

The Reddit post supposedly compares Bitcoin Cash’s (BCH) value to that of BTC since BCH was first identified. It reads, “The first fork of bitcoin is down 90% in BTC value since its inception. Bitcoin is the real Bitcoin.” It includes an image showing data from GitHub that is meant to support the argument, but it all falls apart from there.

Falkvinge points out that the claim is “materially and categorically wrong.” If you look at the actual historical data, the value of BCH has not fluctuated more than around 5%.

He also points to the use of the phrase “first fork” of BTC, a reference to BCH. However, BCH was not the first fork of BTC. A hard fork can be either a code fork or a chain fork. BCH is a chain fork, but there were a number of code forks seen on the BTC blockchain prior to the split that saw BCH carry on the original definition of digital currency.

The chart values are also completely skewed and the chart type is completely wrong for trying to make the intended comparison. This means that the post’s author literally has no idea what he or she is doing, which eliminates completely the validity of post.

The next point really drives home the absurdity of the post. The chart used by the poster references GitHub activity. In other words, the chart is showing data related to changes in code, as if number of changes in code were an indication of an increase in economic value. If this were the case, a country’s economic value would increase every time new laws were introduced. Everyone already knows that this isn’t the case.

As if the misuse of data to prove a point weren’t enough, there is one final point that buries the information presented in the post. Not only does it try to compare BCH and BTC GitHub data, it compares BTC application code changes to BCH website changes. If that doesn’t leave everyone scratching their heads, I don’t know what will.

The Internet is full of false information—this has been shown time and time again, and usually comes from individuals who don’t have the mental capacity to carry on a conversation above the third-grade level. While most of the false information can be ignored, sometimes it’s important to remind people of its presence and show why people need to be more diligent and challenge the data.

Once readers begin to dig deep into virtually all the r/btc Reddit threads, it becomes apparent that the majority are very good at spreading false narratives, but not so much at sticking to the facts.

Falkvinge closes by encouraging people to question more. If questions are not allowed, that is a sure sign that the data is not being challenged, but the authority. And, authority has no place in cryptocurrency.

Note: Tokens on the Bitcoin Core (SegWit) chain are referenced as BTC coins; tokens on the Bitcoin Cash ABC chain are referenced as BCH, BCH-ABC or BAB coins.

Bitcoin Satoshi Vision (BSV) is today the only Bitcoin project that follows the original Satoshi Nakamoto whitepaper, and that follows the original Satoshi protocol and design. BSV is the only public blockchain that maintains the original vision for Bitcoin and will massively scale to become the world’s new money and enterprise blockchain.

COMMENT

latest news

Pakistan eyes blockchain for digitalization of government processes

Tech 18 April 2019

Pakistan eyes blockchain for digitalization of government processes

A meeting chaired by Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan discussed ways in which technologies such as blockchain could be used to ensure efficiency of government processes.

Read More
Accenture, Generali taps blockchain for employee benefits

Tech 18 April 2019

Accenture, Generali taps blockchain for employee benefits

Global management consulting firm Accenture has teamed up with Generali Employee Benefits to develop what they referred to as a unique employee benefits system powered by blockchain.

Read More
Bitcoin SV and the roadmap to Genesis

Tech 17 April 2019

Bitcoin SV and the roadmap to Genesis

Coming soon will be a network upgrade called Quasar, which is currently scheduled for July 24 and centers on increased scaling capabilities.

Read More