Editorial 1 February 2018

Cecille de Jesus

Kristov Atlas: crypto-economics and decentralized development are critical to the future of Bitcoin

“Economics should not be treated as a second-class citizen to Computer Science, but should be considered in tandem.”

Network security and privacy researcher Kristov Atlas wrote a solid piece outlining the importance of taking economics into consideration when making engineering decisions particularly with Bitcoin. Crypto-economics, he says, is severely undervalued yet critically valuable to securing the future of Bitcoin.

He pointed out specified restrictions in the original design—“points of rigidity” that worked back when Bitcoin was just starting and was known to only a few, but cannot support the ecosystem as it grows. It can be noted that the scaling war persists to this day between big blockers (Bitcoin Cash/BCH) and small blockers (legacy BTC)—who insist that the 1Mb block size limit cannot be increased even though it was clearly a temporary security mechanism that was intended to be raised as necessary. By keeping the block sizes small, the artificial and “immediate need” for second layer solutions was justified—along with the unreasonably high fees that come with it.

“One of the points of rigidity, introduced as a temporary security mechanism, has been repurposed as an economic control. In spite of Satoshi’s legacy of holding economic considerations as a primary value, this has not persisted with all of his successors.”

Consequently, other cryptocurrencies quickly gained traction, as they offered and successfully provided faster and cheaper services. Atlas points out that if we want Bitcoin to survive, the technology should be looked at not merely from a computer engineer’s perspective, but with great consideration allocated to the economic implications of any updates to the system.

“Economic research should be considered seriously and responded to… Economics should not be treated as a second-class citizen to Computer Science, but should be considered in tandem.”

Even just as important is Atlas’ point on decentralized development: development should not be entrusted to a few but opened to a community of developers. Bitcoin Cash employs this system with their open developer community.

It becomes a problem when a few developers gain influence over majority of the community for long periods of time. The community must resist this, as it most likely comes at a price. Individuals will have their own agenda at some point, which is why democratic nations have elections—in general, you can’t trust anyone with power for too long. He points out that whoever the “currently most influential regime” is, this is not—and should not be a permanent situation. We must enforce mechanisms to “protect Bitcoin from the temptations of its future caretakers.”

Note: Tokens on the Bitcoin Core (SegWit) chain are referenced as BTC coins; tokens on the Bitcoin Cash ABC chain are referenced as BCH, BCH-ABC or BAB coins.

Bitcoin Satoshi Vision (BSV) is today the only Bitcoin project that follows the original Satoshi Nakamoto whitepaper, and that follows the original Satoshi protocol and design. BSV is the only public blockchain that maintains the original vision for Bitcoin and will massively scale to become the world’s new money and enterprise blockchain.

COMMENT

latest news

Jimmy Song’s desperate need to be relevant

Editorial 18 February 2019

Jimmy Song’s desperate need to be relevant

The man who is most memorable for his cowboy hat rather than his ideas or creations in the BTC world has created a rambling video attacking Bitcoin SV, CoinGeek founder Calvin Ayre and Dr. Craig Wright. We look at each of his claims one by one.

Read More
Dr. Craig Wright on proof

Editorial 18 February 2019

Dr. Craig Wright on proof

In a Medium post, Dr. Craig Wright attempts to put into simple terms why he is who he is and why most people in the crypto space completely miss the big picture on what Bitcoin is truly about. 

Read More
Bitcoin SV is ready for the world’s business

Editorial 14 February 2019

Bitcoin SV is ready for the world’s business

The Bitcoin world hasn’t been short of amazing, with several new developments since Bitcoin was revitalized in November 2018. Bitcoin SV is proving that by following Satoshi’s original plan of keeping a stable protocol and pursuing massive on chain scaling, it opens up incredible new possibilities.

Read More