Business 10 months agoEli Afram
Dr. Craig Wright “backdating” claims should be taken with a grain of salt
The internet community can be a funny place. If you’re at all a public figure, you can expect to be spat at, ridiculed, accused, and pretty much deemed guilty before any conclusivity.
Dr Craig S Wright is no stranger to being on the receiving end in this manner. Entrenched in a world where every keyboard warrior believes they are judge, jury, and executioner can be taxing. But the burden of proof should always lie with the accuser.
One of the most prominent of websites out there today that many rely on for evidence of sorts, is the “WayBackMachine” – famously known as the “Internet Archive”. If there are any doubts as to the authenticity of a publication date, internet users will flock to http://web.archive.org/ and quickly assess the date of publication, as captured by WayBackMachine’s crawler, snapshotted into its archives.
Certainly, many claims that have been made against Dr Wright place heavy reliance on this tool. Claims that he maliciously backdated information, and attempted to conceal evidence are peppered on forums every time the spectre and possibility of Craig Wright being Satoshi surfaces.
But how much trust should we place on such services and their capacity to provide accurate information in this regard?
The first and most obvious detail to note, is that WayBackMachine is not some immutable database that is resistant to change and modification.
But more interestingly, is this second point: The behaviour of WayBackMachine can be to some degree, piloted by webmasters themselves.
This isn’t some voodoo magic. It is search engines, and archiving tools such as WayBackMachine, functioning as designed. Web developers are very familiar with this concept, but it is very possible (in fact its blindingly easy!) to omit a particular page from appearing in WayBackMachine (or google for that matter), for a defined period of time, simply by placing a couple of meta-tags within the HTML header of a webpage.
Let’s take this opportunity, to see just how easy it is for anyone, to manipulate and control their webpage snapshots, on a site like WayBackMachine.
The above meta-tag in bold instructs most search engines not to index the page. Most search engines therefore, will not show the webpage in their search results.
Further X-Robots-Tag can also be used an element of the HTTP header response for a given URL.
Take the following example as a response:
Now the above will do two things.
The “noarchive” directive will prevent a search engine from creating a “cached” copy of the site. The “unavailable_after” directive ensures that the page does not show up in search results after a specified date and time.
The two directives together are able to completely remove a webpage off-record until a specified date, throwing into question the entirety of the “he created the page in 2014/15” argument.
Simply put, these tools index and cache webpage content in a manner as requested by an author.
Does Dr Wright use such meta-tags in his posts?
His response: “It’s my right to privacy”.
Sure enough, many of the pages that are linked externally from 2011, only show up on the WayBackMachine archive in 2015
Perhaps machines can tell us many things… Much of which can be useful, and usable. But without knowing the ins and outs of any tool, it would be foolish to treat the output of any such tool as conclusive evidence. Search engines, and archivers of this nature are tools to assist both search engine users, SEO specialists, webmasters and web developers. They are not ‘designed’ as a forensic tool.
Further information on the usage of Robot meta tags, you can view Google’s own documentation on the topic here.
Note: Tokens on the Bitcoin Core (segwit) Chain are Referred to as BTC coins. Bitcoin Satoshi Vision (BSV) is today the only Bitcoin implementation that follows Satoshi Nakamoto’s original whitepaper for Peer to Peer Electronic Cash. Bitcoin BSV is the only major public blockchain that maintains the original vision for Bitcoin as fast, frictionless, electronic cash.
Business 13 hours ago
Opposition lawmaker eyes tax policy overhaul for Japan’s crypto market
A Japanese lawmaker has proposed a set of changes to the taxation of virtual currency transactions designed to remove the current barriers to growing trading volumes in Japan. The move is seen as the result ...
Business 13 hours ago
Blockchain comes to Philippine healthcare system
Blockchain-based healthcare platform HEX Innovation Ltd has partnered with the University of Perpetual Help Dalta Medical Center (UPHDMC) in the Philippines, giving Filipinos access to services powered by blockchain technology. According to HEX, personal health ...
Business 13 hours ago
Vermont agencies studying need for blockchain regulations
Vermont is looking into what actions to take as a response to the growing blockchain industry in the state. The state’s Attorney-General T.J. Donovan said in a press release that his office, along with the ...